 |
|
 |
I have the bulk of this article already worked out for myself. I'm aware that I need to make a record of things like "VPN settings", etc., and was looking forward to reading in this article how I might find out where these settings and many more are recorded. I expected to find the name of the relevant registry key, or the name and location in the filesystem of the relevant file.
The article doesn't deliver.
I'm disappointed. You led me to believe you would tell me those things, but you didn't tell me any more than I already knew.
and by the way, the spelling is "their" when you're talking of property or attributes of a thing - not "there".
Brian
----@
|
|
|
|
 |
|
 |
Do you have any idea how many thousands of areas in the registry I would have to cover for each VPN client out there? Plainly you don't. It's meant to be a list (at this point) to remind you of things you may wish to look into doing.
There is no possible way I could provide you what you are asking unless I did it on a case by case basis there are 100's of VPN clients out there and I just don't have that much time on my hands.
Check out my 7 Part Series on Networking[^]
Spyware Giving You Fits? Read My Latest Article.[^]
Welcome to the CodeProject!- أهلاً بكم في كود بروجكت
- Καλώς ήλθες στο τόπο τωνκοδικων - സീപിയിലേക്കൂ സ്വാഗതം - コード·プロジェクトへようこそ - Добро пожаловатьна - كوڈ ڀراجيكٹ ميں خوش آمديد - ಸೀಪೀ" ಗೆ ಸ್ವಾಗತ
|
|
|
|
 |
|
 |
No. I have no idea how many VPN clients there are. I'm not interested. I came to your article thinking it would give me pointers to data that could be backed up. I used VPN only as an example taken from your bullet points.
Now that I understand that you're not trying to tell anyone anything more specific than "some programs you use might store settings somewhere in the registry and some other programs might store settings in files" I'm no less disappointed.
Maybe next time I backup and rebuild a machine I'll go the extra mile and document where the settings data is located and how it is backed up and restored. This will be helpful to anyone using the same software and operating system, but will be very specific. Maybe I'll start something where interested people can add their own findings and sggestions for the benefit of others.
Brian
----@
|
|
|
|
 |
|
 |
You know I probably have more experience doing this stuff than anybody here. I had a lot to add. I think I'm done here. You and your attitude have pretty much ruined my desire to add anything else to these articles. I wish you well. I'm pretty much sick of this place and you iced it for me.
Check out my 7 Part Series on Networking[^]
Spyware Giving You Fits? Read My Latest Article.[^]
Welcome to the CodeProject!- أهلاً بكم في كود بروجكت
- Καλώς ήλθες στο τόπο τωνκοδικων - സീപിയിലേക്കൂ സ്വാഗതം - コード·プロジェクトへようこそ - Добро пожаловатьна - كوڈ ڀراجيكٹ ميں خوش آمديد - ಸೀಪೀ" ಗೆ ಸ್ವಾಗತ
|
|
|
|
 |
|
 |
And of course, all articles should address your concerns, and none should be aimed at beginners or people who know less than you do.
"And by the way," being condescending to non-English speaking people does not necessarily help either. You should also start sentences with a capital letter, and should not start them with the word "and", if we are being picky.
Corey
|
|
|
|
 |
|
 |
Articles are not a panacea. They are not the perfect solution nor are they an ideal solution. They simply purpose to expose an idea to deeper thought. There is a lot more I had planned for this article. If you go read the other article similar to this one (click my profile icon, click 'my articles' then click on installing Windows XP) there is a conversation I have in that comments area that I think gets more to what each of you so far is after. I will state I could not possibly convey how to backup your VPN settings but I do know of a method that will help you to do that. I just used it the other night to move one application to another computer without actually installing it. It was tricky but it was compact enough I got away with it.
I'm not trying to be condescending either. I'm quite sick right now. My stomach hurts terribly and I just don't feel well. As far as my spelling and punctuation go it does indeed require some work. However if all of us are to benefit from this then you'll have to give me some room in that area and I'll provide more information for you guys in the areas you are requesting.
There is no doubt that both of my articles on Installing Windows XP and Backup up Data could be expanded a lot. When I first released them I was not even sure they would get any page views with this being a code oriented site. Now I know of and am aware of a demand for deeper information I'll do my best to provide it in an understandable way.
I'm probably going to have to publish another article that talks about how to use Sysinternals FileMon and RegMon to observe what files and registry resources are in use by an application. That would be an excellent article and it would compliment the two I've already discussed. But they will certainly take the discussion deeper (and it seems like that is what people want) and hopefully to a level that is more satisfying to the readers.
- Rex
Check out my 7 Part Series on Networking[^]
Spyware Giving You Fits? Read My Latest Article.[^]
Welcome to the CodeProject!- أهلاً بكم في كود بروجكت
- Καλώς ήλθες στο τόπο τωνκοδικων - സീപിയിലേക്കൂ സ്വാഗതം - コード·プロジェクトへようこそ - Добро пожаловатьна - كوڈ ڀراجيكٹ ميں خوش آمديد - ಸೀಪೀ" ಗೆ ಸ್ವಾಗತ
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
 |
|
 |
I don't expect *all* articles to address only my concerns, but I'm interested in any whose title suggests it might help me with something. That's what this forum is about isn't it?
I do expect articles pitched at beginners and experts and all levels in between. That's what makes these forums such a useful resource.
I didn't mean to appear condescending. I'm aware that English is a second language for many users of these forums and meant to help by pointing out a trivial error and suitable correct usage in a friendly way. Everyone now also knows, thanks to your sarcasm, about sentence capitalisation and the rule about the position of "and".
Brian
----@
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
 |
|
 |
Well, your article hasn't got much to do with code, but there are other articles in here that hasn't got much to do with .NET and VS either, and there are articles about coding that are way simpler than the issue you're writing about.
I haven't rated your article, but I think I'd give you a straight 3. In my opinion the article is not bad, but it's not outstanding either.
Since I'd vote low I'll provide you with a few comments which may or may not be useful to you. (is 3 really low? - If we're on a five scale then 3 should be the average, shouldn't it?)
- Know your audience. Are you aiming at the beginner, the intermediate or the advanced user? Assume your audience know nothing, unless you've assumed it as prerequisites. For instance I'd rate exporting registry keys as advanced, and you don't spend much time explaining anything about how to determine what registry keys to export, how to find those keys and in what certain cases this might be an idea.
- Split up your text in smaller, more digestable paragraphs. I think the introduction could easily be improved simply by splitting it in three paragraphs.
- Split up your topic in smaller, more digestable subtopics and deal with them one at the time. For instance "Things you need to have before reformatting and reinstalling is 1) a backup of all your personal data, 2)install disks and files (beginners do not realize this!), 3) drivers and codecs (prefereably updated), 4) settings (settings could be a subcategory of personal files) a) settings in files, b) settings in the registry."
- Use 15 minutes to do a search for similar articles on the net and for articles that could support your article. Both types you can list at the end of your article for "further reading". It is not a shame to get inspiration from similar articles (hmm - needless to say here on Code Project), but of course remember the references if you use other peoples ideas directly.
- Since the article is about backup, then maybe you ought to mention that sometimes you don't have the time to look into this kind of stuff when the times comes that you think it would be nice to reinstall. If the lightning strikes, you should have done all this yesterday, so if you ask me, then prior to system rebuild means today and once every week or whatever frequence that matches the kind of loss you're ready to accept.
- Concerning the backup software I recommend Cobian for all the "hand picked" ini-files.
- When you rebuild the system, then why not split the hard drive into a system drive and a data drive in order to separate as many of the personal data files as possible from the system files? If you're intermediate you can use TweakUI to redirect all the user folders to your data drive, and then browse through the preferences of all your other apps and see how much of it you can redirect (the outlook .pst for instance). This works great with multiboot and "clean" images too (a clean image is my term for an image made immediately after a system rebuild).
- Write a simple tool for backing up a list of hand picked registry keys to supplement Cobian, mention it in your article (and attach it!), and I'll give you a 5
-- modified at 18:12 Tuesday 22nd August, 2006
|
|
|
|
 |
|
 |
I had concluded some of what you said already but honestly your feedback (when implemented) will make this just exactly what it needs to be.
Thank you very much! I'll try to get this done in the next week. When I do I'll reply to this post and if you have time I'd love to hear your comments on the changes.
I only read cp for the articles.
Iron Speed Designer MVP Check out my 7 Part Series on Networking[^]
Spyware Giving You Fits? Read My Latest Article.[^]
|
|
|
|
 |
|
 |
Well thank you for taking your time to write articles and publish them here on code project.
I'll be looking forward to read the edited version
|
|
|
|
 |