Click here to Skip to main content
Click here to Skip to main content

ASP.NET: How to Resolve Client ID

By , 1 Feb 2007
 

Sample image

Introduction

The ASP.NET framework was designed to manage web controls in an ASPX page using code-behind. If you need to validate a control on the client side, you only need to associate that control with validation controls. All of this works great until we have the need to create JavaScript to manage some of these controls on the client side. The issue is that when you add a control, the ID you provide to this control during design time is not the same ID the page renders at run time. For example, create a new web project and add a new ASPX page, and add a TextBox at design time as follows:

<asp:TextBox ID="mytext" Runat="server"></asp:TextBox>

Run the page and view its source. This is what it looks like:

<Input name="mytext" type="text" id="mytext" />

As you can see, there is no problem here because the control is contained on the page. But what happens when the control is contained on a user control or if you are using master pages (ASP.NET 2.0)? Let's take a look by adding a user control to the project. Call it mycontrol.ascx. Now move the TextBox from the ASPX file to the ASCX file. Make a reference to this user control on the ASPX file. Set the ID of this control to myControl. Display the page on a browser and view its source. This is what it looks like:

<Input name="myControl:mytext" type="text" id="myControl_mytext" />

The control ID now has a prefix with the name of its container. In the case of master pages, all ASPX pages associated to a master page are within a container, and there could be multiple levels of containment. So if you use client-side JavaScript to read and manipulate these controls, how do you resolve the actual client side control ID without hard coding this value in your JavaScript.? There are different approaches to solve this. In this article, I provide one possible solution which uses the ASP.NET framework technologies already available. This solution works for all versions of the framework.

Solution

The key to this approach is to create a client side control which is not altered by the server side processing. One the user control, add a hidden input field. Set the value of the input field to a literal server side control. This should look as follows:

<input type=hidden id="ctrlPrefix" name="ctrlPrefix" 
   value='<asp:Literal Runat="server" ID=ctrlPrefix></asp:Literal>'>

An important note to remember is that the hidden input field must be placed on the container. This is important because this is what is used to resolve the container name. On the code behind of the control, add the following code to the Page_Load event:

string []elm =ctrlPrefix.ClientID.Split('_');       
ctrlPrefix.Text = ctrlPrefix.ClientID.Replace(elm[elm.Length - 1],"");

We first get an array of strings from the control client ID. This has the name of the control and its container separated by an underscore. You could also use the control's ClientId property, but you need to remember to add the underscore. The second line just removes the string in the last element of the array from the control's ClientId. This returns the entire prefix including the underscore. Compile the changes and view the page on a browser. This is what it looks like:

<input name="myControl:mytext" type="text" id="myControl_mytext" />
<input type=hidden id="ctrlPrefix" name="ctrlPrefix" value='myControl_'>

There is now a hidden input field with the prefix of all the server side controls. Now, we can move on to the JavaScript which handles the controls. Add a JavaScript file. Call it mycontrol.js. Add this function to the file:

//returns the container prefix as all controls have that on their ids
function getCrtlPrefix()
{
   var prefix;
   var objCrtlPrefix = document.getElementById("ctrlPrefix");

   if (objCrtlPrefix)
       prefix = objCrtlPrefix.value;

   return prefix;
}

This function reads the value in the hidden input field and returns it. We need to add one more function to test the solution. Add the following function:

function readValue(ctrlName)
{
   var prefix = getCrtlPrefix();
   var objCrtl = document.getElementById(prefix + ctrlName);

   if (objCrtl)
       alert ( "Prefix: " + prefix + " - value: " + objCrtl.value);
   else
       alert("not found!");
}

This function displays the value from the text box. We should notice the call to the getCtrlPrefix function made. The name of the control is appended to this string. This resolves the entire client ID. Move to the user control file and add a button on it. This button is used to call the readValue function. Add the following to the ASCX page:

<input type=button value="Read Value" onclick="javascript:readValue('mytext')">

This HTML button fires the function. Now, add the reference to the JavaScript file by adding the following to your control:

<script language="JavaScript" src="mycontrol.js"></script>

Reload the page, enter something on the text box, and press the button. A message box should display the prefix value and the value that was entered on the text box.

Points of Interest

I hope this article can help some of you work around the way the .NET Framework works and can allow you to continue doing your happy client scripting.

History

  • 01-30-2007: Initial version.

License

This article, along with any associated source code and files, is licensed under The Code Project Open License (CPOL)

About the Author

ozkar garcia
Software Developer (Senior) OG-BITechnologies
United States United States
Member

Sign Up to vote   Poor Excellent
Add a reason or comment to your vote: x
Votes of 3 or less require a comment

Comments and Discussions

 
You must Sign In to use this message board.
Search this forum  
    Spacing  Noise  Layout  Per page   
GeneralAltenate onemembersarathmns4 Oct '07 - 1:48 
nice idea. but can we assure that the dynamic client control id generated by asp.net (client id) will have a "_" sign in it?
in these two line you assume that there is a "_" in the ID
 
string []elm =ctrlPrefix.ClientID.Split('_');
ctrlPrefix.Text = ctrlPrefix.ClientID.Replace(elm[elm.Length - 1],"");
 
I find these two lines a better implementation
int index = ctrlPrefix.ClientID.IndexOf("ctrlPrefix");
ctrlPrefix.Text = ctrlPrefix.ClientID.Substring(0, index);
 
What do you think?
 
.NET - The religion I believe

GeneralTry this instead [modified]membercmschick17 Mar '07 - 20:37 
<asp:Button ID="btnContinue" runat="server" Text="Continue" />
 
<script type="text/javascript">
 
   var theValue = document.getElementById('<%=btnContinue.ClientID%>').value;
   alert(theValue);
 
</script>
GeneralMultiple controls with the same namememberSean Feldman2 Mar '07 - 7:02 
What happens if a container0 has a control with Id txt, and the sub container1 as well, and the page itself directly hosts a control with ID txt?
 
When you do readValue('txt') how logically you would distinguish between the one on the page, one hosted by container0, and container1? Something is missing here...
 
Thanks
 
PS: my understanding was that you just want to get the control on the client side by its server-side ID without messing up with containers and generated client-side IDs.
GeneralRe: Multiple controls with the same namememberozkar2 Mar '07 - 8:45 
Nice scenario.
 
If you follow the approach in the article, you then will end up with three text controls. Call them:
page.txt
container.txt
subcontainer.txt
 
You will also have a collection of ctrlPrefix input parameters because you will need one for each container:
container.ctrlPrefix
subcontainer.ctrlPrefix
 
At this point the getCrtlPrefix() JavaScript function will get a collection of controls (ctrlPrefix). This function will need to be modified to support the handling of the collection. Now, you have three controls with the same name different prefixes (ambiguous if you are trying to only use txt - the prefix will be needed), but lets say the control names are not the same (sounds like a more logical approach for HTML) and you want to support nesting levels of containment.
 
The solution will be to change the getCrtlPrefix() and readValue() JavaScript functions to deal with a collection of prefixes. This way you can continue to read the DOM until all the controls are found.
 
This will be a nice feature to add.
 

GeneralRe: Multiple controls with the same namememberSean Feldman2 Mar '07 - 10:08 
Disagree about logical or not logical approach for HTML, since when you use templated controls (in repeater for example), your controls will have the same ID with a different prefix (templating container). So you'd have ctl00_txt, ctl01_txt, etc. Smile | :) So having the same name is quite common.
 
I was wondering if you're planning to keep working on this idea, or it's going to stay as it is right now? Thanks
 
Sean
GeneralRe: Multiple controls with the same namememberozkar5 Mar '07 - 4:18 
IC,
 
Yes, for templated controls this solution too will work because a collection of controls can be found. The Javascript needs to be modified to allow you to iterate thru all the items (same name) in the collection.
 
Yes, I am planning to extend this approach into a server control, so we could just drop it in a form, and it can resolve control names regardless of the levels of containment.
 
Your feedback is useful to see other area of improvements.
 
thanks.
GeneralGreat IdeamemberPeelyBird6 Feb '07 - 21:32 
I've been using ctrl.ClientId for a while to reference items in Wizard controls within my user controls for instance, but it's annoying because you need to use OnPreRender to call ClientScript.RegisterClientScriptBlock to add the javascript with the correct id's at runtime. This method means I can put ALL the client javascript into external js files. Great idea, Thanks. Smile | :)
GeneralRe: Great Ideamemberozkar7 Feb '07 - 4:36 
Yes, the goal of this approach is to not embed any javascript in the code behind.
 
thanks for your feedback
GeneralSorry but …. :memberaromr6 Feb '07 - 2:43 
I think this article is great as a good way to tell people that the id set to an element in the design time is not the id of the element in the run time ( if this element is marked as runat="server").
 
But I think there is a very easy way to get that client Id and embed it into the javascript .
Simply do as follwing:
 
<script language="javascript" type ="text/javascript>
      var x=<% Response.Write("'"+myControl.ClientId+"';" ) %>
      function doSomething()
      {
     Var myControl=document.getElementById(x);
      }
</script>
 
I think this very easy
 
Good luck

GeneralRe: Sorry but …. :memberozkar7 Feb '07 - 4:33 
Yes, your approach will work if you want to have embedded javascript on the page and only a couple of controls. Think about a registration form which may have 10+ elements and if your system design requires separating all the javascript in js files.
 
thanks for your feedback

General General    News News    Suggestion Suggestion    Question Question    Bug Bug    Answer Answer    Joke Joke    Rant Rant    Admin Admin   

Permalink | Advertise | Privacy | Mobile
Web02 | 2.6.130523.1 | Last Updated 1 Feb 2007
Article Copyright 2007 by ozkar garcia
Everything else Copyright © CodeProject, 1999-2013
Terms of Use
Layout: fixed | fluid