## Introduction

For the last two years, every couple of month or so an article appears claiming “C# is faster than VB.NET”. I agree C# is possibly very slightly faster, I won’t argue. Perhaps it is only fair. Perhaps it is to compensate the fact that C# programmers are probably not as good a VB programmers. You understand that, it is time to revive a good old war like we had years ago between Atari and Amiga. If we can't decide which Language is best, let's see **which programmers are best**, whether it is VB programmers or C# programmers.

## The Mac Mahon problem

The problem I want to challenge you is this one.

You have to complete a puzzle made of 24 pieces. The pieces are displayed in the picture at the beginning of this article.

- All the 24 pieces must be used.
- Each piece can be rotated to any orientation.
- Each segment color must match the color of the adjoining segment.
- The puzzle border must be of the same color (red in this case).

This problem can be reproduced on cardboard to play as a solitaire.

## A valid solution

This is one solution of the problem.

As you can see

- It uses all 24 pieces.
- The border is all red.
- Each piece shares a color with each of its neighbours.

## The Challenge

The challenge is to make a program which looks for solution for this puzzle. The program has to count how many solutions the puzzle has, and then do it as fast a possible. The existing code is already searching, but not very fast. I let my computer run 24 hours and it did not complete…

## VB.NET results

Date |
Description |
Result |

14/03/2005 |
First release by Pascal GANAYE |
10,000 results in more than 24 hours. Did not complete |

15/03/2005 |
Added a few optimizations |
106624 solutions in 90 minutes |

## C# results

Date |
Description |
Result |

14/03/2005 |
No submission yet |
- |

17/03/2005 |
Marc Clifton started a C#. |
77,306 solutions in about 60 minutes |

## Other languages

I would love to see another language here. If you have a try, please post something in the forum below.

### Point of Interest

As you can see, each piece is divided in 4 triangles and filled with 3 colours. Mathematically this is a nice problem, because this it is not 24 arbitrary chosen pieces but every single combination. There are 3*3*3*3 = 81 possibilities. But If you remove the duplicates you end up with only 24 different pieces.

## Submission rules

- I will post one submission in each submitted language. You can also use this page forum at the bottom.
- The program can use any sort of optimisation as long as it stays managed .NET and native language (can’t use MSIL).
- All optimisation must be described. Please no hard coded solution.

I suggest a notation structure for the solutions. If you name the piece A0,B0,C0,...X0.

A0 |
B0 |
C0 |
D0 |
E0 |
F0 |

G0 |
H0 |
I0 |
J0 |
K0 |
L0 |

M0 |
N0 |
O0 |
P0 |
Q0 |
R0 |

S0 |
T0 |
U0 |
V0 |
W0 |
X0 |

The rotated version of B0 would be called:

B1 (90 degrees anti-clockwise)

B2 (180 degrees), and

B3 (270 degrees).

Then a solution like this one

could be written like this:

B2 D0 I0 L0 J0 G0
A0 C2 V0 S0 T2 O3
K0 F0 X0 W0 U0 Q3
H2 E0 P2 R2 M2 N3

or even as a single line like this:

B2D0I0L0J0G0A0C2V0S0T2O3K0F0X0W0U0Q3H2E0P2R2M2N3

This will probably help to compare our results.

You can see mine here.

## Last notes

I hope you realize, I don't take this language war very seriously. I just love the Mac-Mahon problem. How can we live without knowing for sure how many solutions there are?