12,076,727 members (46,834 online)
Rate this:
See more:
I need a function that return if a certain point is inside a directx 3d model(.x)...

I have tried but i can´t get it to work so i need some help.

Something like this:

```public bool IsInsideModel(Vector3 point, Model model)
{
//This would of course be nice but i don't think such function exists...
//return model.Contains(point);
}
```

Any suggestions will be appreciated.

This is not for a game engine or realtime rendering so the computing time is not an issue.
Posted 21-Mar-11 11:40am
Edited 25-Mar-11 8:08am
v4
orc_orc_orc 21-Mar-11 17:45pm

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/4963110/determine-if-x-y-z-point-is-inside-a-shape-defined-by-an-array-of-points

http://www.softsurfer.com/Archive/algorithm_0104/algorithm_0104B.htm

i dont know if they will help but take a look at it.

Rate this:

## Solution 1

The good news: it can be done. The bad news: A precise test is computationally expensive and therefore probably too slow to be of any use in real time rendering.

First off, it works only on convex objects. Concave objects would have to be broken down into two or more convex objects and then tested individually.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concave_polygon[^]

Let's call the point you want to test P, the verices of the object VX and their normals NX. Then you will have to compute the cross product between the NX and (VX - P). The cross product will tell you wether P is inside the object or not and this must be true for every VX of the object.

Seriously, you are probably trying to program a collision test for some 3D engine, right? In this case The test is usually done against a much simpler object as a substitute for the real 3D object, usually those are boxes or spheres which approximate the space filled by the real 3D object and are far easier to test. It's very common in graphics to sacrifice some precision in order to gain performance.

Top Experts
Last 24hrsThis month
 Richard MacCutchan 380 Sergey Alexandrovich Kryukov 360 Jochen Arndt 350 OriginalGriff 315 F-ES Sitecore 220
 OriginalGriff 2,855 Dave Kreskowiak 2,836 Richard MacCutchan 2,174 CPallini 1,632 Sergey Alexandrovich Kryukov 1,416