C++ string constructor - why bool treated as char?

Question

1.00/5 (1 vote)

See more:

Hi! Might be already described here but did not find :-(
Lets say, I have defined class with two operators (besides other f-nalty):

class MyClass
{
      public:
           operator bool() const;
           operator const std::string() const;
}

Now, whan I use this class the way a'la:

MyClass mc;
if(mc) // the bool operator invoked
{
      std::string myString{ mc };
}

If I expect that string constructed using copy operator and const std::string operator of MyClass but this is incorrect :-(

Instead of

operator bool() const;
used and string constructed using

basic_string( std::initializer_list<CharT> ilist,
              const Allocator& alloc = Allocator() );

Same happens if I write:

std::string a{true, true, true, false, true, 'a'};
or std::string b{true};

I see that this is initializer list but isn't it limited by char type elements? Does that mean that any value that can be converted to char value is allowed here?

What I have tried:

I've played with it using Compiler explorer and that's seems correct!?

Posted 26-Nov-22 4:39am

Jaan Laasalu 2021

Updated 26-Nov-22 15:45pm

Add a Solution

Comments

0x01AA 26-Nov-22 11:00am

And the code for operator bool() const; and also operator const std::string() const; loos like?

Richard MacCutchan 26-Nov-22 11:43am

You have not explained exactly what happens when you run this code.

2 solutions

Solution 2

change

MyClass mc;
if(mc) // the bool operator invoked
{
      std::string myString{ mc };
}

to:

MyClass mc;
	if (mc) // the bool operator invoked
	{
		std::string myString(mc);
	}

will call your

MyClass::operator const std::string();

as you seen, {} is different from () sometimes

Posted 26-Nov-22 15:45pm

longjmp

Add a Solution

This content, along with any associated source code and files, is licensed under The Code Project Open License (CPOL)

Jaan Laasalu 2021 · Accepted Answer · 2022-11-26T06:01:00

Solution 1

And the code for operator bool() const; and also operator const std::string() const; loos like?

smth like this :

class test
{
    std::string data;

    public:

    test(const std::string& d) : data{d}
    {}

    operator bool() const 
    {
        return !data.empty();
    }

    operator const std::string&() const
    {
        return data;
    }

};

-------------------------

You have not explained exactly what happens when you run this code.

.....
test t{"hello"};

....

if (t)
{
  std::string s{t};
  sdt::cout << s << "\n";
}

When I run it in console it printed out "face" (ascii for 0x01)

Posted 26-Nov-22 6:01am

Jaan Laasalu 2021

Comments

Jaan Laasalu 2021 27-Nov-22 5:58am

> as you seen, {} is different from () sometimes
Hi! Once more - thnx, but i concern more about why string constructed not using copy constructor (using std::string& operator) but using bool operator of test class?
In conclusion - need to cover all by unit tests..

longjmp 28-Nov-22 2:41am

I think you found the key.
======================================
Using and string construction, use
basic_string( std::initializer_list<chart> ilist,
const Allocator& alloc = Allocator() ).
=====================
std::initializer_list<chart> can accept {true, true, true, false, true, 'a'}.
Since sizeof(CharT) >= sizeof(bool), it will result in an "implicit conversion" from bool to CharT.

And this code compiles fine without errors or warnings.
USHORT u16 = 8.
std::initializer_list<uint32> list32 = {u16, u16};

C++ string constructor - why bool treated as char?

2 solutions

Solution 1

Solution 2

Add your solution here

Preview 0

C++ string constructor - why bool treated as char?

2 solutions

Solution 1

Solution 2

Add your solution here

Preview 0

Existing Members

...or Join us