The main problem is the design of your class. You should not make all methods static. To design a class make an outline listing the variables and methods you'll need. Wherever you might repeat code e.g print the game grid make a separate private method.
Such as:
public class TicTacToe
{
private boolean player1turn;
private int score;
private char[9] grid;
public void Intro();
public void StartNewGame();
public int GetPlayerChoice();
private void ResetGrid();
private void UpdateGrid();
private void ShowGrid();
private int CheckForWinner();
}