Click here to Skip to main content
15,897,273 members

Welcome to the Lounge

   

For discussing anything related to a software developer's life but is not for programming questions. Got a programming question?

The Lounge is rated Safe For Work. If you're about to post something inappropriate for a shared office environment, then don't post it. No ads, no abuse, and no programming questions. Trolling, (political, climate, religious or whatever) will result in your account being removed.

 
GeneralRe: Would you hire or not and why? :) Pin
Nelek24-Nov-16 1:29
protectorNelek24-Nov-16 1:29 
AnswerRe: Would you hire or not and why? :) Pin
V.23-Nov-16 21:48
professionalV.23-Nov-16 21:48 
AnswerRe: Would you hire or not and why? :) Pin
F-ES Sitecore23-Nov-16 22:05
professionalF-ES Sitecore23-Nov-16 22:05 
AnswerRe: Would you hire or not and why? :) Pin
Tomaž Štih23-Nov-16 22:27
Tomaž Štih23-Nov-16 22:27 
AnswerRe: Would you hire or not and why? :) Pin
Mel Padden23-Nov-16 22:30
Mel Padden23-Nov-16 22:30 
AnswerRe: Would you hire or not and why? :) Pin
Kirill Illenseer24-Nov-16 21:46
Kirill Illenseer24-Nov-16 21:46 
AnswerRe: Would you hire or not and why? :) Pin
Vaso Elias25-Nov-16 3:51
Vaso Elias25-Nov-16 3:51 
AnswerRe: Would you hire or not and why? :) Pin
Steve Naidamast25-Nov-16 6:53
professionalSteve Naidamast25-Nov-16 6:53 
I have been responsible as a software engineer to make many hiring recommendations.

I always go with the person who demonstrates outside interests in extending their abilities by doing their own development projects.

In this case however, the description of Candidate B shows symptoms of being a "prima-donna", which could be very disruptive over all.

If the position requires someone who can teach and mentor other developers than Candidate A would also not fit your requirements, though he or she may be the better fit in terms of personality in your organization.

As a result, both of your candidates have potential negatives against their hiring and both are equal in terms of the negatives.

You can do one of two things here...

1) Interview several more candidates to either get a better fit or determine if the current two warrant further investment of consideration.

2) If you want to make a choice between your current candidates than follow my suggestions below
which I have used for a 100% success rate during my own interviewing experiences.
A) Develop a basic, oral, technical exam that has questions based upon the minimal
   requirements of the position as well as your minimal, overall, technical requirements.
   The idea is not to always get the correct answer but to see how each candidate answers
   each question.  If candidate A answers less questions correctly but providers a much
   better response in handling him or herself this will indicate a personality that is
   more adept at handling difficult issues.  If candidate B answers the same questions
   more correctly and well than you also have to understand this more experienced
   candidate's capabilities.  Are they just good at taking oral exams or do the responses
   sound as if the person feels comfortable with the questions due to an interest in the
   profession.

 B) Prior to the oral exam, ensure that you make each candidate feel as comfortable as
    possible within the interview environment.  Open up the session by getting the
    candidate to talk about themselves by trying to see if both can find some common
    ground such as a shared interest.  The idea here is to go against the common practice
    of attempting to intimidate candidates thinking this is the best way to see how they
    react under stress.  This is a fool's way of interviewing prospective personnel and
    only demonstrates a company that has no caring for the person itself.  Such interviews
    are more in line with military-style interrogations than anything close to a session
    where a need for an understanding of the person in front of you is critical.

 C) If after you have given a candidate the oral examination you feel that he or she has
    answered well, has felt comfortable with the questioning, and has answered your
    minimum required questions correctly change back to a longer discussion about the
    candidate themselves.  Find out if they like software development enough to do it on
    the side and if so what projects they enjoy working on.  Ask what type of equipment
    they have for their personnel development projects.  Ask what other interests they
    have, which can be a key factor for a good employee.  For example if a candidate
    enjoys reading about the sciences, though this may sound great up front it can also
    indicate a person with a very clinical personality, which often does not mesh well
    with a team.  If he or she likes to read science-fiction this could indicate a person
    with imagination.  If history, this could indicate a candidate who enjoys research.
    Both of these traits could do very well for you since both would bring to the table an
    enthusiasm to get the job done.

The idea behind such an interview style is to get as complete an understanding of the person before you in an interview. And do this by not making them feel threatened but by getting them to open up to you honestly and fairly. By doing this you yourself will get a feeling of who you would be more comfortable working with. You may find that candidate A in your situation may be the better team member than the self-taught developer. However, my experience it is that self-taught professionals are far superior in many cases over the university trained person since they have real world development skills and personalities to match.

Two last suggestions. Women are not that inclined these days to enter the computer profession simply because the nature of the field has encouraged them to ignore it as a potential career path.

If you interview a women of any age, ensure that when she enters the room you stand up as a sign of courtesy and respect. Then ask if you could get her some coffee or water. Never address a lady by her first name simply because this is what young people may do or it is the style today. Ladies today still respect traditional courtesies afforded them even if they are slightly surprised by it.

For a male candidate do not try to get overly "chummy" with them, no matter the rapport you may develop. This will only appear suspicious to many, even to men within the same culture. Be professional, friendly, and above all courteous.

If you have any further questions on interviewing techniques, you may contact me at my business email below...
Steve Naidamast
Sr. Software Engineer
Black Falcon Software, Inc.
support@blackfalconsoftware.com

AnswerRe: Would you hire or not and why? :) Pin
Gerry Schmitz26-Nov-16 15:40
mveGerry Schmitz26-Nov-16 15:40 
AnswerRe: Would you hire or not and why? :) Pin
BubingaMan28-Nov-16 2:03
BubingaMan28-Nov-16 2:03 
AnswerRe: Would you hire or not and why? :) Pin
mbb011-Dec-16 3:54
mbb011-Dec-16 3:54 
AnswerRe: Would you hire or not and why? :) Pin
James Curran9-Dec-16 14:03
James Curran9-Dec-16 14:03 
GeneralI don't know whether to celebrate or cry, at this discovery Pin
Mark_Wallace23-Nov-16 12:10
Mark_Wallace23-Nov-16 12:10 
GeneralRe: I don't know whether to celebrate or cry, at this discovery Pin
RossMW23-Nov-16 13:15
professionalRossMW23-Nov-16 13:15 
GeneralRe: I don't know whether to celebrate or cry, at this discovery Pin
Mycroft Holmes23-Nov-16 13:58
professionalMycroft Holmes23-Nov-16 13:58 
GeneralRe: I don't know whether to celebrate or cry, at this discovery Pin
Mark_Wallace23-Nov-16 19:11
Mark_Wallace23-Nov-16 19:11 
GeneralRe: I don't know whether to celebrate or cry, at this discovery Pin
Daniel Pfeffer23-Nov-16 20:57
professionalDaniel Pfeffer23-Nov-16 20:57 
GeneralRe: I don't know whether to celebrate or cry, at this discovery Pin
Mark_Wallace23-Nov-16 22:58
Mark_Wallace23-Nov-16 22:58 
GeneralRe: I don't know whether to celebrate or cry, at this discovery Pin
Daniel Pfeffer23-Nov-16 23:08
professionalDaniel Pfeffer23-Nov-16 23:08 
GeneralRe: I don't know whether to celebrate or cry, at this discovery Pin
Mark_Wallace24-Nov-16 0:10
Mark_Wallace24-Nov-16 0:10 
QuestionWho would you hire and why? Pin
TheOnlyRealTodd23-Nov-16 8:47
professionalTheOnlyRealTodd23-Nov-16 8:47 
GeneralRe: Who would you hire and why? Pin
harold aptroot23-Nov-16 8:55
harold aptroot23-Nov-16 8:55 
GeneralRe: Who would you hire and why? Pin
Jon McKee23-Nov-16 21:29
professionalJon McKee23-Nov-16 21:29 
GeneralRe: Who would you hire and why? Pin
harold aptroot23-Nov-16 23:16
harold aptroot23-Nov-16 23:16 
GeneralRe: Who would you hire and why? Pin
Jon McKee24-Nov-16 8:42
professionalJon McKee24-Nov-16 8:42 

General General    News News    Suggestion Suggestion    Question Question    Bug Bug    Answer Answer    Joke Joke    Praise Praise    Rant Rant    Admin Admin   

Use Ctrl+Left/Right to switch messages, Ctrl+Up/Down to switch threads, Ctrl+Shift+Left/Right to switch pages.


Straw Poll

Were you affected by the geomagnetic storms this past weekend?
Communication disruptions, electrified pipes, random unexplained blue-screens in Windows - the list of effects is terrifying.
  Results   27 votes