Click here to Skip to main content
15,890,370 members

The Insider News

   

The Insider News is for breaking IT and Software development news. Post your news, your alerts and your inside scoops. This is an IT news-only forum - all off-topic, non-news posts will be removed. If you wish to ask a programming question please post it here.

Get The Daily Insider direct to your mailbox every day. Subscribe now!

 
NewsOAuth and API Providers: Come on guys. Pin
Terrence Dorsey24-Jul-12 10:28
sitebuilderTerrence Dorsey24-Jul-12 10:28 
NewsThe scramble to avoid home broadband metering Pin
Terrence Dorsey24-Jul-12 10:28
sitebuilderTerrence Dorsey24-Jul-12 10:28 
GeneralRe: The scramble to avoid home broadband metering Pin
enhzflep24-Jul-12 21:06
enhzflep24-Jul-12 21:06 
GeneralRe: The scramble to avoid home broadband metering Pin
jschell25-Jul-12 7:56
jschell25-Jul-12 7:56 
GeneralRe: The scramble to avoid home broadband metering Pin
enhzflep26-Jul-12 2:59
enhzflep26-Jul-12 2:59 
GeneralRe: The scramble to avoid home broadband metering Pin
jschell27-Jul-12 11:54
jschell27-Jul-12 11:54 
GeneralRe: The scramble to avoid home broadband metering Pin
enhzflep27-Jul-12 18:02
enhzflep27-Jul-12 18:02 
GeneralRe: The scramble to avoid home broadband metering Pin
jschell28-Jul-12 6:30
jschell28-Jul-12 6:30 
enhzflep wrote:
You gasoline is metered at the pump. Oh noes! Those elephanters are gonna charge me more for gas if I'm taking my wife out for the evening than if I was taking the kids to school. Yes, your argument appears that foolish to me.


That analogy is no more apt than the other.

In both cases it is is not economically feasible or actually impossible to determine the actual usage.

On the other hands ISPs are more than capable of metering by type. Certain ISPs have made various restrictions related to this for years. And there are recent cases where users have been disconnected for their type of usage.

enhzflep wrote:
As for cutting you off for the remainder of the month if you exceed some limit, what exactly is your point?


The point is that ISPs, at least some of them, ALREADY limit volume. So they certainly don't need a legal mandate to protect themselves from that.

enhzflep wrote:
Should the light users subsidise the heavy users, because the heavy users are paranoid that their usage patterns will cost them more in the future?


Again, ALL of the proposals that I have seen that allowed for metering ALSO allowed for limitations based on the type (not volume) of usage. And that specifically allows a ISP to set up deals that either requires a customer to pay more for using a specific service (from someone other than the ISP) or to completely preclude access at all.

An analogy for that last case is the most recent dispute between DirectTV (cable) and Viacom dispute. Also note that this sort of dispute comes up every couple of years in the cable industry.

But I would support such agreements if ISPs allowed themselves to be regulated as a monopoly and as such rates, including increases, and any such limitations by type would need to be justified and approved by an outside committee. At least where I am that is how the electric company works.
GeneralRe: The scramble to avoid home broadband metering Pin
AspDotNetDev25-Jul-12 8:09
protectorAspDotNetDev25-Jul-12 8:09 
NewsWhen robots start telling each other stories... Pin
Terrence Dorsey24-Jul-12 10:27
sitebuilderTerrence Dorsey24-Jul-12 10:27 
NewsThree Months with Sublime Text 2 Pin
Terrence Dorsey24-Jul-12 10:27
sitebuilderTerrence Dorsey24-Jul-12 10:27 
NewsSo, who really did invent the Internet? Pin
Terrence Dorsey24-Jul-12 10:26
sitebuilderTerrence Dorsey24-Jul-12 10:26 
GeneralRe: So, who really did invent the Internet? Pin
Chris Losinger24-Jul-12 10:43
professionalChris Losinger24-Jul-12 10:43 
NewsThe Mystery of 355/113 Pin
Terrence Dorsey24-Jul-12 10:26
sitebuilderTerrence Dorsey24-Jul-12 10:26 
NewsTech's center of gravity shifts north to San Francisco Pin
atbennett24-Jul-12 10:15
atbennett24-Jul-12 10:15 
General(Un)forgettable password Pin
Wendelius24-Jul-12 2:59
mentorWendelius24-Jul-12 2:59 
JokeRe: (Un)forgettable password Pin
Andrew Rissing24-Jul-12 3:55
Andrew Rissing24-Jul-12 3:55 
GeneralRe: (Un)forgettable password Pin
Gary Wheeler25-Jul-12 0:29
Gary Wheeler25-Jul-12 0:29 
GeneralRe: (Un)forgettable password Pin
KP Lee25-Jul-12 20:59
KP Lee25-Jul-12 20:59 
NewsAmazon offers to pay vocational training for warehouse staff Pin
atbennett23-Jul-12 15:42
atbennett23-Jul-12 15:42 
GeneralRe: Amazon offers to pay vocational training for warehouse staff Pin
Albert Holguin23-Jul-12 16:36
professionalAlbert Holguin23-Jul-12 16:36 
NewsSummer Reading... and Programming [video] Pin
Terrence Dorsey23-Jul-12 10:54
sitebuilderTerrence Dorsey23-Jul-12 10:54 
NewsBSON (Binary JSON) and how your Web API can be even faster Pin
Terrence Dorsey23-Jul-12 10:54
sitebuilderTerrence Dorsey23-Jul-12 10:54 
NewsImplementing Fast Interpreters Pin
Terrence Dorsey23-Jul-12 10:53
sitebuilderTerrence Dorsey23-Jul-12 10:53 
NewsStep by step from jQuery to Backbone Pin
Terrence Dorsey23-Jul-12 10:53
sitebuilderTerrence Dorsey23-Jul-12 10:53 

General General    News News    Suggestion Suggestion    Question Question    Bug Bug    Answer Answer    Joke Joke    Praise Praise    Rant Rant    Admin Admin   

Use Ctrl+Left/Right to switch messages, Ctrl+Up/Down to switch threads, Ctrl+Shift+Left/Right to switch pages.