Welcome to the Lounge

trønderen wrote:

If I were given the responsibility for a state machine implementation like that, I would immediately run to my boss asking for permission to rewrite the whole thing as a table driven machine.

#include <stdio.h>
#include <conio.h>

// Fn ptrs defs
typedef  void (*RT)( int input );
typedef  RT (*TER)( int input );

// Forward declarations
extern TER state1( int input );
extern TER state2( int input );
extern TER state3( int input );

// First state
TER state1( int input )
{
    printf( "one\t" );
    return input < 10 ? (TER)&state2 : (TER)NULL;
}

// Second state
TER state2( int input )
{
	printf( "two\t" );
	return (TER)&state3;
}

// Third state
TER state3( int input )
{
    printf( "three\t" );
    return (TER)&state1;
}

int main(int argc, char* argv[])
{
    int n;

    // Set Start state
    TER state = (TER)&state1;

    // Exercises the state machine. Ends when state == NULL
    for ( n = 0 ; state ; ++n ) {
        // Executes the current state (state variable) then goes to the next state
        state = (TER)( state( n ) );
    }

    printf( "\n\nPress any key\n" );
    getch();

	return 0;
}

honey the codewitch wrote:

with impossible to follow pointer arrays

honey the codewitch wrote:

I hate function pointer dispatch code in general.

Because at some point you'll have to debug and maintain it, and you end up with impossible to follow pointer arrays hiding the flow of your app.

honey the codewitch wrote:

at some point you'll have to debug and maintain it

then you will do peek and poke on the generated code.

If you really are as ignorant of the code generated by Visual FA as you are of the code generated by the gcc compiler

trønderen wrote:

But you state that you do see a need to maintain the Visual FA generated code. So you do not trust your generator/compiler.

honey the codewitch wrote:

That would be fair, if I ever said that. However, I did not say that.

trønderen wrote:

our subject line clearly suggests that you expect to have full control over the gotos produced by your Visual FA generator.