The Lounge is rated Safe For Work. If you're about to post something inappropriate for a shared office environment, then don't post it. No ads, no abuse, and no programming questions. Trolling, (political, climate, religious or whatever) will result in your account being removed.
I'd be blaming the disk controller doing a bad job of power management rather than the OS. And frankly, based on my own experience, I've had much worse luck recovering from sleep sessions than hibernating.
My desktop systems run 24/7 (and have for years), but I always let my laptops hibernate - especially the older ones that otherwise take a long time to do a full reboot. Maybe I'm just lucky, but I've never encountered the sort of situation you're describing.
And I'll bring this up just because I hate them with a passion: Are your drives by any chance misfortune Seagate?
Having used SSDs for many years, and tested them by putting them in TIVO devices...
Any fear I had of the SSDs getting worn out were put to rest. I got 4 years of TIVO on an OLD SSD I had run for over a year. It eventually died. But that was 4 years of continuous writes!
That said. I replace ALL my SSDs within 3-4yrs for my workstations, usually upgrading in Size along the way! (Whereby they become backup (emergency recovery) devices for cold spares, usually created weekly. The restore process (if primary drives are gone), pop those in to spare, fire it up, and restore from most recent. This had the advantage of being testable and timed. We know how long it takes. And it's 2-4hrs until we are back up and running).
I find that I need to restart every now and then because docking and undocking on my machine causes Windows to lose it's marbles. Slowly it begins not to redraw sections of the screen, starting with menu's. If it was Windows 3.1 I'd describe it as running out of resources. Amazing how far we've come.
If Windows 10 then I don't believe shutdown or restart really do either of those things. Internally I reckon they sleep and come back as so many times you get your applications back in the same state they were in when you started
That is even after turning off windows fast start in the power options
for ages I think the only real restart is one where updates are installed
For me, depends what my mood is - often I just leave them, so they auto-sleep (like the monitors do). Or I might shut them down - these days, my machines take such a short time to boot (my Lenovo P1 boots in about 10 seconds), it's no hardship to wait through a boot sequence (of course, there's getting your environment back again - Windows could do with a feature like macOS where it'll reopen all the documents/applications you had open when you shut it down).
And most of my machines are on the Windows Insider Fast ring, so get a new Windows version roughly each week, so there's at least one restart a week...
As for docks - I use a couple of Dell Thunderbolt docks regularly and I never power cycle those.
Java, Basic, who cares - it's all a bunch of tree-hugging hippy cr*p
I believe that a computer that is turned off is less likely to have data corruption/loss during mid-night thunderstorm -- mine are always powered off when work is done. The USA Midwest can have impressive night time thunderstorms.
My laptop is used strictly on trips as a portable substitute for my desktop, so it gets powered up and down each time I use it.
However, my company makes products that are based on Windows CE (6.0, in our case), and that OS has counters involved in timing that overflow about every 49 days, so our User Manual recommends power cycling the unit at least once a month. If the software is written correctly, that overflow can be handled, but I learned years ago to assume that software is never written correctly.
I seldom power off any of my computers, but I do a reboot usually about every week-ten days (more on Windows machines, less on Linux). I will power off/unplug during a severe electrical storm if I am around because, while I am protected by surge protection and a UPS, a close-in lightning strike can overload a surge protector or UPS. (I live on top of a ridge, surround by trees, two of which have been struck in the last 20 years.)
I am against powering off machines. Studies have shown that many chip failures occur due to the thermal stress induced by the warm-up/cool down cycle. This, of course, is dependent on the chip construction.
Though I hear before breakfast that squirrels' nuts are a fancied entree.
after many otherwise intelligent sounding suggestions that achieved nothing the nice folks at Technet said the only solution was to low level format my hard disk then reinstall my signature. Sadly, this still didn't fix the issue!