|
I already know he does not have this installed - and most of my customers for this program won't either. That's why I linked to MFC statically.
But after you mentioned this issue, I googled it and found that linking statically can cause crashes:
http://social.msdn.microsoft.com/Forums/en-US/vcgeneral/thread/b6badcd6-297d-4c73-a589-02507eb79548[^]
This has drawbacks.
- The CRT code is including more than once. Increasing the memory footprint of your application.
- Sharing the MFC in a DLL reduces the overall consumption of memory in the system
- MFC Extension DLL's are no longer supported.
- Allocating memory in one module (DLL,EXE) and freeing memory in another will cause a crash.
- Information like the locale are used in each module and are not shared. setlocale in the exe will not affect the locale in the DLL (this is good and bad depending on the design of the modules)
- There I heard rumors that there is a discussion to stop any support of statically linked version of CRT, MFC and ATL.
I do have two modules - an EXE and a DLL. I can't think of a case where I allocate memory in one and release it in the other, but I'm not 100% certain and maybe there are other hazards.
I asked my tester if he'd install the redistribution package. Maybe that's why the VC++ 6 compilation isn't crashing - that's dynamically linked rather than statically. If dynamic linking for VS2008 doesn't crash, then I'll continue development on VC++ 6 and stop worrying about it. I'm just very nervous about ignoring this without knowing why it's happening. In my experience, that always comes back to bite me in the butt.
|
|
|
|
|
No real answers, but for what it is worth ...
Have you gotten a list of all the programs that he has installed on each machine? Any programs on both that are not common? Or perhaps common, but dubious?
I had a real nasty situation once where the problem was some sort of interaction between AOL software and something else - I believe the HP printer driver. (Fortunately, it didn't make a difference if my software was installed.)
Anything notable about his hardware configuration? Limited RAM or something?
Is he close enough geographically that you could bring over a machine and put together a remote debugging setup?
One thing that I find surprising is that you are able to use the same source code under both VC++ 6 and 2008, considering the non-standard dialect of C++ used in version 6 and not in later versions.Please do not read this signature.
|
|
|
|
|
Avi Berger wrote: Have you gotten a list of all the programs that he has installed on each machine? Any programs on both that are not common? Or perhaps common, but dubious?
Not yet. It's a pain in the neck to do that, and I'm already asking a lot of him because his are the only computers on which it crashes. Instead, I asked him to try not loading stuff, but it still crashed. It crashed when he turned off all startup programs (in msconfig), it crashed when he booted into diagnostic mode (though msconfig), and it even crashed when he booted into safe mode and ran it!
I just noticed he said he got a blue screen crash after rebooting from msconfig, but he didn't say after which reboot. Either way, that makes it sound like there's something funny on his system. Why should NOT loading something cause a blue screen crash?
I just emailed him to ask what software he was running on both computers.
Avi Berger wrote: Is he close enough geographically that you could bring over a machine and put together a remote debugging setup?
I think he lives a few hundred miles away from me, so that would be a long trip.
Avi Berger wrote: One thing that I find surprising is that you are able to use the same source code under both VC++ 6 and 2008, considering the non-standard dialect of C++ used in version 6 and not in later versions.
It was originally written with VC++ 6 and then moved over to Visual Studio 20008, so it was pretty easy to move it back. I had to make some very small changes to make it work on both, but nothing much.
I just realized I did something pretty stupid when compiling - in fact, I'm not sure why it's working at all. I had it set for "Use standard Windows libraries" rather than "Use MFC in...((static or dynamic))". I just rebuilt it in two versions, one statically linking to MFC, one dynamic, and gave him a link to the redistributables (for dynamic linking). I haven't heard back yet. I wonder if, after all this pain, that's all it was. And yet, I still don't understand why it doesn't work for him and it works for everyone else.
|
|
|
|
|
Hi,
when a program runs fine on one system and not on another, there may be a difference in the environment, such as a missing DLL, or a different version of DLL. However, it may also indicate a simple bug in the program: running fine on a system is no proof of correctness.
Here are some ideas, the list is not complete!
- regional settings may be different, causing a conversion to sometimes fail. Example: date formatting could be dd-MMM-yyyy or MM/dd/yyyy, a string gets parsed fine in the one situation and not in the other. Now if the program also lacks decent error detection and reporting, you will be completely in the dark.
- some data gets stored somewhere, in a file, in registry, whatever; it is different on different systems and some values (or absence thereof) is not handled well. Example: assume a recent file list is kept in registry, it does not exist on some system, and as a result m_pRecentFileList->m_arrNames[0] is null (or undefined) and can not reliably be dereferenced.
Advice:
- check your code for proper error detection, reporting and handling;
- check your code dealing with inputs (registry, files, network locations, ...) as that is the greatest area of variance;
- check your system configuration, such as amount of memory.
|
|
|
|
|
Those are good points about the environment. Something like this would explain how it could be something specific about his system that isn't fixed by booting into Safe mode or not running Startup programs. I don't think it's date-format-related or it would be crashing on the computer of the Australian guy who's been testing the program, too. He's tried it on multiple systems with no problems.
I check return codes for everything - I went over every line of the startup code again.
Isn't the recent file list always stored in the registry for XP and above? My program targets XP and above. Anyway, I know it is on his system because my crash dump report includes the registry settings. I use this statement to enable and load the MRU files:
LoadStdProfileSettings(4);
My program does do a lot with input and output, and the InitInstance function mainly figures out paths for input and output. The input path is wherever the executable is. If the path ends up more than 260 characters, the program will put up an error message and terminate. Output is a subdirectory of MyDocs, which is created if it's not found. I check every return code and terminate cleanly if something goes wrong. I've traced through all the filename/path stuff in the debugger and it's working correctly.
He sent me some system specs from a diagnostic program he runs. I should look at it more carefully.
|
|
|
|
|
I am not familiar with LoadStdProfileSettings(4);. What does it return when there aren't any MRU files (in registry or where ever they get stored)?
one more typical mistake: one cannot store a file in a folder that does not yet exist.
|
|
|
|
|
It has no return code. Here's what Microsoft says about it:
http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/xbkh2k4h.aspx[^]
CWinApp::LoadStdProfileSettings
Call this member function from within the InitInstance member function to enable and load the list of most recently used (MRU) files and last preview state.
void LoadStdProfileSettings(
UINT nMaxMRU = _AFX_MRU_COUNT
);
I definitely create the output folder before I store anything in it.
|
|
|
|
|
I believe it is related to Heap Corruption.
Most probable reason is Buffer overrun.
Check for memory copy, memory concatenation etc in our code in that flow.
Some where in the code, you are using more memory than allocated.
These errors are hard to detect and crash on those machines, where it wont get that memory location, which is overrun from the allocation, because it might have benn already reserved.Величие не Бога может быть недооценена.
|
|
|
|
|
Are you in a position to be able to setup a remote debugging connection?
This allows you to step through the code on the target computer using the debugger on your PC.
There are some hoops to jump through to set it up, but it may be invaluable in helping to track down the root cause of the issue.If you vote me down, my score will only get lower
|
|
|
|
|
I've never done this and don't know how. What do you have to do to set it up?
|
|
|
|
|
I would recommend you do a search on the microsoft site for remote debugging in relation to the development platform your using. (Actually a straight google search for "remote debugging" should turn up what you need)
As the implementation of this has varied slightly over the years, I cannot give any direct description on how to perform it for your environment.If you vote me down, my score will only get lower
|
|
|
|
|
When I'm having issues that I cannot reproduce, then I use remote desktop/remote assistance to take control of the customer computer and install Windows Debug Tools (WinDbg).
WinDbg allows you to debug applications:
1) To see call stack while debugging then you need to upload Program Database files (PDB) generated with the EXE/DLL files.
2) To see source code then you need to upload the source used to compile the application.
3) To see values of variables (and not just addresses), then you need to compile the application without optimization turned on.
P.S. I would add the following to the problem line you have shown:
# Check that m_pRecentFileList != NULL
# Change m_arrNames to a proper container and check the size of that instead of using m_nSize
|
|
|
|
|
Yes, yes, and yes - thanks. I can see this is the direction I need to go.
I have WinDbg installed, but my knowledge of how to use it is minimal. I've used it to view crash dumps, but never for remote debugging and I don't know how that works. I need to google remote debugging for more detailed instructions.
Snakefoot wrote: I would add the following to the problem line you have shown:
# Check that m_pRecentFileList != NULL
# Change m_arrNames to a proper container and check the size of that instead of using m_nSize
Yeah, it's becoming clear to me that I need to check this pointer before trying to use it. The reason I didn't is that I didn't think there was any way it could be invalid after I'd made the call to LoadStdProfileSettings(4);. Could you tell me under what circumstances this structure might not be populated properly after this call? There's no return value to check with LoadStdProfileSettings.
I don't know what you mean by "change m_arrNames to a proper container". What is a "proper container". Confession: I learned to program in the pre-Windows DOS world (I am old) and I'm more adept with procedural programming than object-oriented programming.
|
|
|
|
|
A proper container is one that keeps track of its allocation like std::vector or MFC::CSimpleArray.
But I see that you are using CRecentFileList(), and it seems to be without such features.
|
|
|
|
|
I made a small change to the program, and now it's crashing on my own development system - which is sort of bad, but also sort of good.
The problem is not the line I quoted. It's crashing when it tries to run the app. I think I must have a buffer overrun somewhere, though I have no idea where. I looked at Bounds Checker but it costs $1500. Is there a cheaper alternative?
Geez - I am losing it, or I need more sleep or something. I deleted something crucial, that is all. Back to the original problem...modified on Wednesday, March 17, 2010 6:02 PM
|
|
|
|
|
Snakefoot wrote: A proper container is one that keeps track of its allocation like std::vector or MFC::CSimpleArray.
But I see that you are using CRecentFileList(), and it seems to be without such features.
I put in a check that the list exists, and for some reason I cannot fathom, it is not created properly on this one guy's system, though it works fine for everyone else.
I can't imagine what he can be doing on his computer that would prevent this standard MFC call from working properly. Does anyone know? I'd rather not do it all manually if I don't have to. I'd rather detect systems that don't support it, but I don't know of any reason why a system would not support it.
Can anyone make a guess on this?
|
|
|
|
|
I fixed the problem. I still have no idea why the standard call wasn't working on his system. But I changed this:
LoadStdProfileSettings(4);
to
CString strSection = "Recent File List";
CString strEntryFormat = "File%d";
m_pRecentFileList = new CRecentFileList(1, strSection, strEntryFormat, 4);
m_pRecentFileList->ReadList();
And voila! No crashes - it's working fine.
I can't believe I spent a week and a half of my life on this. On the plus side, my startup code is vastly cleaner after 10 days of intense scrutiny.
|
|
|
|
|
Hi,
NOTIFYICONDATA nid;
ZeroMemory(&nid,sizeof(nid));
nid.cbSize = sizeof(NOTIFYICONDATA);
nid.hWnd = hWnd;
nid.uID = 0;
nid.uFlags = NIF_ICON | NIF_MESSAGE | NIF_TIP;
nid.uCallbackMessage = WM_USER;
nid.hIcon = LoadIcon(NULL, IDI_APPLICATION);
(nid.szTip,"Double-Click To Maximize.");
I have successfully got my application to show in the system tray but I want to add menu items when the user right clicks on the icon in the system tray.
Thank you.Andrew McIntyre
|
|
|
|
|
MrMcIntyre wrote: I have successfully got my application to show in the system tray but I want to add menu items when the user right clicks on the icon in the system tray.
You have to display the menu yourself. The CTrayIcon class in this article[^] encapsulates the display of a tray icon, and displays a menu in the OnTrayNotify method.Java, Basic, who cares - it's all a bunch of tree-hugging hippy cr*p
CodeProject MVP for 2010 - who'd'a thunk it!
|
|
|
|
|
Hi Andrew,
I hope this code will help you out.
What i normally do is first setup the basic funtionality for the try icon, something like this:
this->notifyIcon1->BalloonTipIcon = System::Windows::Forms::ToolTipIcon::Info;
this->notifyIcon1->Icon = (cli::safe_cast<System::Drawing::Icon^ >resources->GetObject(L"notifyIcon1.Icon")));
this->notifyIcon1->Text = L"Helios Options";
this->notifyIcon1->Visible = true;
this->notifyIcon1->MouseDoubleClick += gcnew System::Windows::Forms::MouseEventHandler(this, &Form1::notifyIcon1_MouseDoubleClick)
<pre>
Then i create a funtion that takes a couple of arguments to write and display certain text:
<pre>private: System::Void DoNotify(System::String^ Titlex, System::String^ Message, int Timeout)
{
notifyIcon1->ShowBalloonTip(Timeout,Titlex,Message,System::Windows::Forms::ToolTipIcon::Info);
}
<pre>
I then use the funtion like this:
<pre>DoNotify("Helios Minimised","Helios is still running\r\nDouble click icon to maximise",5);
I then handle the form resize funtion, this will show and hide the main window
private: System::Void Form1_Resize(System::Object^ sender, System::EventArgs^ e)
{
if(FormWindowState::Minimized == this->;WindowState)
{
DoNotify("Helios Minimised","Helios is still running\r\nDouble click icon to maximise",5);
this->Hide();
}
else if(FormWindowState::Normal == this->WindowState)
{
}
}
Then finally i hadle the function we created a event handler for at the notifyicon:
private: System::Void notifyIcon1_MouseDoubleClick(System::Object^ sender, System::Windows::Forms::MouseEventArgs^ e)
{
this->Show();
this->WindowState = FormWindowState::Normal;
}
I hope this will help you a little more.
Let me know if there is anything else i can help with.
Louis
|
|
|
|
|
| Is that C# code on the example or C++. Andrew McIntyre
|
|
|
|
|
|
NOTIFYICONDATA nid;
memset(&nid, 0, sizeof(NOTIFYICONDATA));
nid.cbSize = sizeof(NOTIFYICONDATA);
nid.hWnd = hWnd;
nid.uID = 1;
nid.uFlags = NIF_ICON | NIF_MESSAGE | NIF_TIP;
nid.uCallbackMessage = WM_USER + 200;
nid.hIcon = LoadIcon(NULL, IDI_INFORMATION);
lstrcpy nid.szTip, ("Test Tip");
Shell_NotifyIcon(NIM_ADD, &nid);
Hi Louis,
Can you help me fix this code so it can display the notify icon Title set as "Test" and in the code allow me to create menu items.
Thank you.Andrew McIntyre
|
|
|
|
|
Hi Andrew,
I have not used the Notifyicon in normall C++ yet, though the implementation thereof would not differ
much from C++/Clr i think. I could code something up for you, though are you only using C++? Cause this is all very simple using Clr. You simply add a Context menu strip and edit it via the normal GUI editor, and associate it then with your NotifyIcon from the editor or from code.
Louis
|
|
|
|
|
Louis,
I need it to be in C++.Andrew McIntyre
|
|
|
|
|
General 
News 
Suggestion 
Question 
Bug 
Answer 
Joke 
Praise 
Rant 
Admin 
Submit an article or tip
