Click here to Skip to main content
15,502,869 members

Bugs and Suggestions

   

General discussions, site bug reports and suggestions about the site.

For general questions check out the CodeProject FAQs. To report spam and abuse Head to the Spam and abuse watch. If you wish to report a bug privately, especially those related to security, please email webmaster@codeproject.com

 
GeneralRe: Why Do We Suddenly Have to Approve an Article From Sasha? Pin
thatraja10-Mar-12 0:27
professionalthatraja10-Mar-12 0:27 
SuggestionThe new Tip / Trick submission form. Pin
OriginalGriff9-Mar-12 2:22
mveOriginalGriff9-Mar-12 2:22 
GeneralRe: The new Tip / Trick submission form - Addendum Pin
OriginalGriff9-Mar-12 2:34
mveOriginalGriff9-Mar-12 2:34 
GeneralRe: The new Tip / Trick submission form. Pin
Chris Maunder9-Mar-12 3:08
cofounderChris Maunder9-Mar-12 3:08 
GeneralRe: The new Tip / Trick submission form. Pin
OriginalGriff9-Mar-12 3:31
mveOriginalGriff9-Mar-12 3:31 
GeneralRe: The new Tip / Trick submission form. Pin
OriginalGriff9-Mar-12 3:43
mveOriginalGriff9-Mar-12 3:43 
GeneralRe: The new Tip / Trick submission form. Pin
OriginalGriff9-Mar-12 4:32
mveOriginalGriff9-Mar-12 4:32 
BugComments on specific article revisions = wrong! Pin
Colin Eberhardt8-Mar-12 23:59
Colin Eberhardt8-Mar-12 23:59 
Chris, thanks for your earlier explanation of why comments are associated with specific revisions of an article:

http://www.codeproject.com/Messages/4184889/Are-comments-specific-to-an-article-revision.aspx[^]

However, whilst the intention is that comments relating to article quality, whilst it is in the review process, do not make it through to the final - published article. It looks like this doesn't really work in practice!

I spotted a typo on my recently published article, which is now awaiting moderation, and as a result have a number of 'my vote of 5' style comments here:

http://www.codeproject.com/script/Articles/ArticleVersion.aspx?aid=342715&av=506455#_comments[^]

and here:

http://www.codeproject.com/script/Articles/ArticleVersion.aspx?aid=342715&av=505884#_comments[^]

and of course, here, in the right place:

Plotting Circular Relationship Graphs with Silverlight


I have never spotted this problem before, so I am guessing this is a new feature? Also, I am pretty sure that in the past minor modifications that I made to an article did not require moderation.

Can I suggest that it is made much more obvious that comments on an article which is awaiting moderation are specifically for the purpose of flagging quality issues? This might be quite hard to do with the way that it is currently set up because it is presented in exactly the same way as the regular article commenting mechanism, so I suspect regulars would just go into 'auto-pilot'.

(Any chance the messages on my article revisions could be moved to the main article? - id this is a big deal, don;t worry about it)

Regards, Colin E.
Colin Eberhardt
Twitter | Blog | LinkedIn


modified 9-Mar-12 9:37am.

GeneralRe: Comments on specific article revisions = wrong! Pin
Pete O'Hanlon9-Mar-12 1:02
mvaPete O'Hanlon9-Mar-12 1:02 
GeneralRe: Comments on specific article revisions = wrong! Pin
Colin Eberhardt9-Mar-12 1:23
Colin Eberhardt9-Mar-12 1:23 
GeneralRe: Comments on specific article revisions = wrong! Pin
Colin Eberhardt9-Mar-12 1:27
Colin Eberhardt9-Mar-12 1:27 
GeneralRe: Comments on specific article revisions = wrong! Pin
Chris Maunder9-Mar-12 19:02
cofounderChris Maunder9-Mar-12 19:02 
GeneralRe: Comments on specific article revisions = wrong! Pin
Pete O'Hanlon9-Mar-12 20:44
mvaPete O'Hanlon9-Mar-12 20:44 
GeneralRe: Comments on specific article revisions = wrong! Pin
Colin Eberhardt10-Mar-12 2:08
Colin Eberhardt10-Mar-12 2:08 
GeneralRe: Comments on specific article revisions = wrong! Pin
Chris Maunder10-Mar-12 8:49
cofounderChris Maunder10-Mar-12 8:49 
GeneralRe: Comments on specific article revisions = wrong! Pin
Colin Eberhardt10-Mar-12 22:47
Colin Eberhardt10-Mar-12 22:47 
QuestionInformation about updating answers Pin
Perić Željko8-Mar-12 23:29
professionalPerić Željko8-Mar-12 23:29 
AnswerRe: Information about updating answers Pin
Chris Maunder9-Mar-12 2:58
cofounderChris Maunder9-Mar-12 2:58 
GeneralRe: Information about updating answers Pin
Perić Željko9-Mar-12 8:38
professionalPerić Željko9-Mar-12 8:38 
SuggestionUsability - plz make hotkey legend more prominent Pin
bill 7778-Mar-12 15:33
bill 7778-Mar-12 15:33 
GeneralRe: Usability - plz make hotkey legend more prominent Pin
OriginalGriff8-Mar-12 22:16
mveOriginalGriff8-Mar-12 22:16 
SuggestionAre comments specific to an article revision? Pin
Colin Eberhardt8-Mar-12 10:32
Colin Eberhardt8-Mar-12 10:32 
GeneralRe: Are comments specific to an article revision? Pin
Chris Maunder8-Mar-12 10:40
cofounderChris Maunder8-Mar-12 10:40 
GeneralRe: Are comments specific to an article revision? Pin
Colin Eberhardt8-Mar-12 10:45
Colin Eberhardt8-Mar-12 10:45 
BugUnexpected error when attempting to retrieve preview HTML. Pin
harold aptroot8-Mar-12 3:43
harold aptroot8-Mar-12 3:43 

General General    News News    Suggestion Suggestion    Question Question    Bug Bug    Answer Answer    Joke Joke    Praise Praise    Rant Rant    Admin Admin   

Flags: AnsweredFixedUnable to replicate

Use Ctrl+Left/Right to switch messages, Ctrl+Up/Down to switch threads, Ctrl+Shift+Left/Right to switch pages.