Click here to Skip to main content
12,945,697 members (49,559 online)
Click here to Skip to main content
Add your own
alternative version


141 bookmarked
Posted 7 Sep 2009

High performance WPF 3D Chart

, 7 Sep 2009 CPOL
Rate this:
Please Sign up or sign in to vote.
An article on WPF 3D performance enhancement techniques


When using WPF for 3D graphics, many people have concerns over the performance. Following the guidelines from Microsoft online help, I built a 3D surface chart, as shown in the picture above. The surface chart has more than 40,000 vertices and more than 80,000 triangles. The performance is still fine. The project also includes 3D scatter plot which has a large number of data points. You can build the project, feel the performance of WPF 3D and decide whether WPF 3D is suitable for your 3D data visualization.

1. Basic 3D Setup

This section briefly goes through the steps for building 3D graphics using WPF. Although there are many tutorials on WPF 3D, I still give a brief review here to help understand the class structure of this project.

The WPF 3D is displayed within the Viewport3D UI elements. The three basic components are:

  • Camera
  • Light
  • 3D model

For 3D chart, we are not concerned too much about the camera and light. Those properties are set in the XAML file, as shown below. The 3D model will be set in C# code.

<Window x:Class="WPFChart.Window1"



    Title="WPF 3D Chart" Height="500" Width="600">
        <Viewport3D Name="mainViewport" >
                <OrthographicCamera x:Name="camera" 





	                Position="0,0,2" />
                <ModelVisual3D x:Name="Light1">
                     <DirectionalLight Color="White" Direction="1,1,-1"/>

The root element is a Window. Inside the window, we use Grid layout. Those two elements are provided by Visual Studio when we build the project. Inside the grid, we add a Viewport3D to hold the 3D object. Under the Viewport3D, we have a camera, a directional light.

We added the camera and light in the XAML file. Now, we add the 3D model in C# code. The mesh structure (type System.Windows.Media.Media3D.MeshGeometry3D) consists of four parts of data:

  1. Vertices location
  2. Connection between vertices
  3. Normal direction of vertices
  4. Texture mapping coordinate of each vertex

The vertices location is represented by a Point3D structure.

System.Windows.Media.Media3D.Point3D point0 = new Point3D(-0.5, 0, 0);
System.Windows.Media.Media3D.Point3D point1 = new Point3D(0.5, 0.5, 0.3);
System.Windows.Media.Media3D.Point3D point2 = new Point3D(0, 0.5, 0);

Those points are put into Positions array of the mesh structure.

System.Windows.Media.Media3D.MeshGeometry3D triangleMesh = new MeshGeometry3D();


Three vertices make a triangle. The vertices connections are described by three integers, which are the indices of the 3 vertices in the Positions array.

int n0 = 0;
int n1 = 1;
int n2 = 2;

The 3 indices of a triangle are added to the TriangleIndices array.


The order of the indices decides whether the triangle is front surface or back surface. The front surface and back surface usually have different properties. The WPF 3D display also needs to know the normal direction of the vertices.

System.Windows.Media.Media3D.Vector3D norm = new Vector3D(0, 0, 1);

We will discuss the texture mapping in a later section. The above code only shows one triangle. By combining many triangles, we can get a mesh structure. Now, we will attach material properties to the mesh surface.

System.Windows.Media.Media3D.Material frontMaterial = 
			new DiffuseMaterial(new SolidColorBrush(Colors.Blue));

Combining mesh and material, we can get a 3D model.

System.Windows.Media.Media3D.GeometryModel3D triangleModel = 
			new GeometryModel3D(triangleMesh, frontMaterial);

The GeometryModel3D object also has a transform property. We will discuss it in the next section.

triangleModel.Transform = new Transform3DGroup();

The 3D model we created will be attached to a visual element:

System.Windows.Media.Media3D.ModelVisual3D visualModel = new ModelVisual3D();
visualModel.Content = triangleModel;

The ModelVisual3D object will be displayed in Viewport3D:


This involves quite a lot of steps. Model3D class in this project helps to generate a ModelVisual3D object. If we run the program, we will see a blue triangle. We cannot rotate it yet. In the next section, we will show how to rotate this 3D model.

2. Rotate 3D Model

In this section, we will use the mouse to rotate the 3D model. Rotating the 3D model in WPF is easy, but we want to implement our own selection function later. Therefore, we need to keep a track of the transform when we rotate the 3D model.

In order to catch the mouse event, we cover the Viewport3D with a transparent Canvas. The mouse down, move and up events handlers of the canvas will be added to the window class.

We can either change the camera location or change the transform property of the 3D model to rotate the 3D object. For this project, we will modify the transform property of the 3D model. The transform property of a 3D model can be described as System.Windows.Media.Matrix3D. We will build a special transform class to use this matrix.

public class TransformMatrix
   public Matrix3D m_viewMatrix = new Matrix3D();
   private Point m_movePoint;

The Matrix3D member variable m_viewMatrix is used to rotate the 3D object. The TransformMatrix class will handle the mouse events and rotate the model.

public class TransformMatrix
    public void OnMouseMove(Point pt, System.Windows.Controls.Viewport3D viewPort)
        double width = viewPort.ActualWidth;
        double height = viewPort.ActualHeight;
        if (Keyboard.IsKeyDown(Key.LeftShift) || Keyboard.IsKeyDown(Key.RightShift))
            double aY = 180 * (pt.X - m_movePoint.X) / width;
            double aX = 180 * (pt.Y - m_movePoint.Y) / height;

            m_viewMatrix.Rotate(new Quaternion(new Vector3D(1, 0, 0), aX));
            m_viewMatrix.Rotate(new Quaternion(new Vector3D(0, 1, 0), aY));
            m_movePoint = pt;

The 3D rotation is implemented in the mouse move event. The view matrix will rotate according to the offset of the current mouse position and previous mouse position m_movePoint. We scale the rotate so the model moves 180 degrees when we move the mouse from one side of the window to another side. You can change this rotation sensitivity.

To use the TransformMatrix class, we can add a TransformMatrix variable to the window class, and call the mouse event handler of TransformMatrix object at the corresponding mouse events of the window class.

public partial class Window1 : Window
    public WPFChart.TransformMatrix m_transformMatrix = new WPFChart.TransformMatrix();
    public void OnViewportMouseMove(object sender, 
			System.Windows.Input.MouseEventArgs args)
        Point pt = args.GetPosition(mainViewport);
        if (args.LeftButton == MouseButtonState.Pressed)
            m_transformMatrix.OnMouseMove(pt, mainViewport);
            Transform3DGroup group1 = triangleModel.Transform as Transform3DGroup;
            group1.Children.Add(new MatrixTransform3D(transformMatrix.m_ m_viewMatrix));

After we modify the transform matrix, we need to set a new view matrix to the 3D model’s transform property.

3. Auto Zoom

The triangle we used in the previous two sections has the data range -0.5 ~ 0.5. The camera we used has a default width of 2. Camera center is at (0, 0). So the triangle is in the camera view range. If the 3D object is out of camera range, the 3D object will not be shown in Viewport3D. We can change the camera position to keep the 3D object in camera view. Here, we use a different approach. We will add another matrix to project the 3D object into the camera view range.

public class TransformMatrix
     private Matrix3D m_viewMatrix = new Matrix3D();
     private Matrix3D m_projMatrix = new Matrix3D();

     public Matrix3D m_totalMatrix = new Matrix3D();

The projection matrix will transform the 3D model into camera view range. The 3D object then goes through the view matrix, as discussed in the previous section. The total matrix will be set into the 3D model transformation.

The projection matrix is set by the data range of the 3D object.

public class TransformMatrix
     public void CalculateProjectionMatrix(double xMin, double xMax, 
		double yMin, double yMax, double zMin, double zMax, double k)
          double xC = (xMin + xMax) / 2;
          double yC = (yMin + yMax) / 2;
          double zC = (zMin + zMax) / 2;
          m_projMatrix.Translate(new Vector3D(-xC, -yC, -zC));

          double sX = k*2 / (xMax - xMin);
          m_projMatrix.Scale(new Vector3D(sX, sX, sX));

          m_totalMatrix = Matrix3D.Multiply(m_projMatrix, m_viewMatrix);

The last parameter of the function is a scale factor. A value of 0.5 means we want data to take 50% of the screen. Each time, we change the view matrix or projection matrix, we need to calculate the total matrix. We also need to change our code in the window class. Instead of setting the view matrix m_viewMatrix to the 3D model transform property, we will set the total matrix m_totalMatrix to the 3D object transformation.

4. Select in 3D

The WPF provides the mouse hit test function. However, it may not be suitable for a 3D chart. For example, a 3D scatter plot may have several thousand data points. Running hit test on those data points is not practical in terms of performance. Therefore, we should turn off the IsHitTestVisible property of the Viewport3D.

To implement our own selection function, we need to know where a 3D point is projected on the 2D screen. In the previous section, we add a matrix transform to the 3D object. In addition to this transform, the 3D object also goes though other transforms before it is projected onto 2D screen. For example, the camera has its own transform. The orthographic camera we used keeps the default width of 2. It points to the –z direction. You can check the camera transform matrix and will find out that it is an identity matrix. Therefore, we will ignore the camera transform. However, we still have one transform that has not been discussed yet, i.e. the final transform which projects the camera range to Viewport3D.

  1. The center of the camera (0, 0) is projected to the center of the Viewport3D (w/2, h/2).
  2. The scale factor of transform is decided by x-axis only. Y axis has the same scale as the x-axis.
  3. Y axis of the camera points up while the y axis of the Viewport3D points down.

Following those rules, the VertexToScreenPt() function of the TransformMatrix class calculates the screen location of a 3D point.

public class TransformMatrix
    public Point VertexToScreenPt(Point3D point, 
		System.Windows.Controls.Viewport3D viewPort)
        Point3D pt2 = m_totalMatrix.Transform(point);

        double width = viewPort.ActualWidth;
        double height = viewPort.ActualHeight;

        double x3 = width / 2 + (pt2.X) * width / 2;
        double y3 = height / 2 - (pt2.Y) * width / 2;

        return new Point(x3, y3);

The input Point3D parameter is the 3D location of a point, the return Point value is its location on the 2D screen. To test this function, we will move the mouse onto one corner of the triangle, and compare the actual screen coordinate with predicated position by the VertexToScreenPt() function.

A text block is added to the bottom of the window and acts as a status pane. At the mouse move event, we can hold the mouse left button and rotate the triangle to different location, as we did in the previous section. We can then move the mouse to the top-right corner of the triangle. The actual mouse position can be obtained from the mouse event argument. We will compare this reading with the calculated position of the triangle vertex.

public partial class Window1 : Window
    public void OnViewportMouseMove(object sender, 
		System.Windows.Input.MouseEventArgs args)
         Point pt = args.GetPosition(mainViewport);
         if (args.LeftButton == MouseButtonState.Pressed) 
             String s1;
             Point pt2 = m_transformMatrix.VertexToScreenPt
			(new Point3D(0.5, 0.5, 0.3), mainViewport);
             s1 = string.Format("Screen:({0:d},{1:d}), Predicated:({2:d}, 
			H:{3:d})", (int)pt.X, (int)pt.Y, (int)pt2.X, (int)pt2.Y);
             this.statusPane.Text = s1;

Test Selection

Look at the status pane display, we know TransformMatrix.VertexToScreenPt() function returns the correct screen position. We can rotate the triangle to a different location, and still get matching results. Based on the TransformMatrix.VertexToScreenPt() function, we implement the select function in this project.

Understanding the screen transformation also helps us implement the drag function in mouse move event. The mouse will be used to drag the 3D model when the shift key is down. We want the 3D model to move exactly by the same amount as that mouse move on the screen. Therefore, we use camera width to Viewport3D width ratio as the scale factor when we drag the model.

public class TransformMatrix
    public void OnMouseMove(Point pt, System.Windows.Controls.Viewport3D viewPort)
        double width = viewPort.ActualWidth;
        double height = viewPort.ActualHeight;

	if (Keyboard.IsKeyDown(Key.LeftShift) || Keyboard.IsKeyDown(Key.RightShift))
            double shiftX = 2 *(pt.X - m_movePoint.X) /( width);
            double shiftY = -2 *(pt.Y - m_movePoint.Y)/( width);
            m_viewMatrix.Translate(new Vector3D(shiftX, shiftY, 0));
            m_movePoint = pt;
         m_totalMatrix = Matrix3D.Multiply(m_projMatrix, m_viewMatrix);

5. Basic Classes of the Project

In the previous section, we displayed a triangle. A 3D object consists of many triangles. Mesh3D and ColorMesh3D classes in this project are used for single color 3D models and color 3D models respectively. For single color 3D objects, we have the Mesh3D class:

public class Mesh3D
     private Point3D [] m_points;            // x, y, z coordinate
     private Triangle3D [] m_tris;           // triangle information
     private Color m_color;                  // mesh color

     public double m_xMin, m_xMax, m_yMin, m_yMax, m_zMin, m_zMax;

The single color mesh model consists of an array of 3D points and array of triangle’s vertices’ indices. The whole mesh model has a single color which is described by the third member variable m_color. The last six member variables are the data range of the mesh model.

The Triangle3D class defines the vertex index of a triangle.

public class Triangle3D
    public int n0, n1, n2;

Based on Mesh3D class, we can build different basic shapes, such as, cube, cylinder, cone, and sphere. They are child classes of Mesh3D class. Those basic shapes are need in 3D charts. Basic shapes

The Mesh3D class is for data processing. We have to convert it into WPF ModelVisual3D type for 3D display. We also want to merge different mesh models into a single 3D model to enhance the performance of 3D display. The Model3D class is designed for this purpose. The picture below describes the class structure of this project. class structure

The 3D data in a different 3D chart has a different form. This project only demos the scatter plot and surface plot. They are represented by ScatterChart3D and SurfaceChart3D classes. The 3D chart data goes through a few conversions before the pass to the Viewport3D. First, it generates an array of Mesh3D (or ColorMesh3D) objects. This Mesh3D array is then passed to the Model3D class and produces a single ModelVisual3D object. The ModelVisual3D object is added to the Viewport3D for display.

6. Color 3D Model

WPF 3D model can set the color using brush. If a 3D chart has many color objects, creating many brushes of different colors will degrade the performance. Instead we can create an image brush for color mapping. The image has a different color at different locations. We can use different mapping coordinates for different colors.

The true color has 2563 = 16777216 colors. Those colors need a 4096x4096 mapping image. Normally, the 3D charts only use limited number of colors. For different 3D charts, we will use different color layouts. For bar chart and scatter plot, we use 16 color values in each channel. There will be 163 = 4096 colors. This should be enough to mark different categories. The size of the mapping image will be 64x64.

For surface charts, we often pseudo color the surface according to the z value of the 3D plot, as shown in the first picture of this article. The picture below shows the color mapping method we use for pseudo color. The x axis is normalized z value. The y axis shows the RGB color that corresponds to the z value.

Psedo color

The TextureMapping class implements both color layouts. Here, we only discuss the color layout for scatter plot. You can check the source code of the TextureMapping class for pseudo color mapping. The mapping image has a size of 64x64. The blue channel has 16 values, so the blue channel takes 1/4 of each row. We then change the green channel. For each red value, the green and blue values take 4 rows.

The WritableBitmap will be used in the image brush.

public class TextureMapping
    public DiffuseMaterial m_material;
    private void SetRGBMaping()
         WriteableBitmap writeableBitmap = 
		new WriteableBitmap(64, 64, 96, 96, PixelFormats.Bgr24, null);

First, we set up a 64x64 RGB bitmap. In order to access the bitmap memory, we need to lock the bitmap.

     byte* pStart = (byte*)(void*)writeableBitmap.BackBuffer;
     int nL = writeableBitmap.BackBufferStride;

     for (int r = 0; r < 16; r++)
         for (int g = 0; g < 16; g++)
             for (int b = 0; b < 16; b++)
                 int nX = (g % 4) * 16 + b;
                 int nY = r*4 + (int)(g/4);

                 *(pStart + nY*nL + nX*3 + 0) = (byte)(b * 17);
                 *(pStart + nY*nL + nX*3 + 1) = (byte)(g * 17);
                 *(pStart + nY*nL + nX*3 + 2) = (byte)(r * 17);

In order to access the bitmap memory directly, we need to use unsafe code. We also need to enable the unsafe mode in the project setting. For each channel, we use 16 levels. The pixel location in the bitmap is calculated from RGB value. The color at the corresponding pixel is set.

       writeableBitmap.AddDirtyRect(new Int32Rect(0, 0, 64, 64));


       ImageBrush imageBrush = new ImageBrush(writeableBitmap);
       imageBrush.ViewportUnits = BrushMappingMode.Absolute;
       m_material = new DiffuseMaterial();
       m_material.Brush = imageBrush;

After the color pixels are set, we set the dirty flag so the WPF will update the bitmap element. Once we finish accessing the bitmap memory, we need to unlock the bitmap so the WPF can update the bitmap display. We then create an image brush using the bitmap. At last, we create a material using image brush.

Later, when we use mapping image for color painting, we need know the mapping location of a certain color. This is provided by the GetMappingPosition() function of the TextureMapping class.

public class TextureMapping
      public Point GetMappingPosition(Color color)
            int r = (color.R) / 17;
            int g = (color.G) / 17;
            int b = (color.B) / 17;

            int nX = (g % 4) * 16 + b;
            int nY = r * 4 + (int)(g / 4);

            return new Point((double)nX /63, (double)nY /63);

To use the mapping image for color, we get the color of the each vertex, then find the mapping coordinate of that color, and add the mapping coordinate to the TextureCoordinates array of the MeshGeometry3D object. This is implemented in the SetModel() function of the Model3D class.

Using the Code

This project provides some base classes for high performance 3D charts. It is not a complete library. You still need to add more classes to display grid, label, title. The picture below shows the testing program. The data is generated randomly within a certain range. Therefore, it does not look real, You can plugin your data. Check the code in the window class to see how to use those classes.

Software GUI

The project provides the following functions:

  1. Generate a 3D model for display.

    Check the message handler for "Test" button to see how to generate the display model for 3D chart.

  2. Rotate the 3D model.

    Hold the mouse left button to rotate the 3D model.

  3. Drag the 3D model.

    Hold the mouse left button and shift key to drag the model.

  4. Zoom

    Press "+" or "-" key to zoom

  5. Select

    Use mouse right button to draw a rectangle and select data in the 3D chart.

Finally, you can change the data number, (then click test button) to test the performance of the WPF3D.

Points of Interest

WPF is very easy to use to display some simple objects. However, you need to do a lot of work if you want to display a larger amount of data. Those performance enhancement tasks seem trivial, but need a lot of testing and debugging. I hope this project helps you decide whether you want to use WPF for your 3D data display, or continue using other techniques, such as OpenGL.


  • 7th September, 2009: Initial release


This article, along with any associated source code and files, is licensed under The Code Project Open License (CPOL)


About the Author

Jianzhong Zhang
Software Developer (Senior)
United States United States
No Biography provided

You may also be interested in...


Comments and Discussions

Questionlarge amount of data Pin
Member 1278921817-Oct-16 0:34
memberMember 1278921817-Oct-16 0:34 
SuggestionHow to use UniformSurfaceChart3D Pin
Member 1122782012-Jan-16 23:49
memberMember 1122782012-Jan-16 23:49 
GeneralMy vote of 5 Pin
Member 12536400715-May-15 3:55
memberMember 12536400715-May-15 3:55 
GeneralMy vote of 5 Pin
Arun Kumar K S18-Mar-15 2:24
professionalArun Kumar K S18-Mar-15 2:24 Pin
Member 1074734021-Jan-15 5:53
memberMember 1074734021-Jan-15 5:53 
QuestionYet more higher performance 3D WPF charting Pin
Pasi Tuomainen11-Jan-15 10:07
memberPasi Tuomainen11-Jan-15 10:07 
Questionhow to add labels on axes? Pin
dado7927-Oct-14 4:03
memberdado7927-Oct-14 4:03 
SuggestionAdvanced 3D chart with customizable axes created with Ab3d.PowerToys library Pin
abenedik5-Jun-14 23:32
memberabenedik5-Jun-14 23:32 
QuestionHow can I add axis to surface plot? Pin
gukemanbu20-Jan-14 23:39
membergukemanbu20-Jan-14 23:39 
GeneralMy vote of 5 Pin
ibyk303-May-13 9:32
memberibyk303-May-13 9:32 
GeneralRe: My vote of 5 Pin
ibyk309-May-13 8:34
memberibyk309-May-13 8:34 
QuestionDisplaying Axes in Uniform Surface Chart 3D Pin
Faizan S Kazi27-Feb-13 4:24
memberFaizan S Kazi27-Feb-13 4:24 
AnswerRe: Displaying Axes in Uniform Surface Chart 3D Pin
ibyk3010-May-13 3:52
memberibyk3010-May-13 3:52 
QuestionCopyright HP? Pin
Member 985428221-Feb-13 10:30
memberMember 985428221-Feb-13 10:30 
Questionsquare mesh3d Pin
brennt28-Sep-12 9:08
memberbrennt28-Sep-12 9:08 
QuestionLines in 3D space Pin
ensamblegl6-Aug-12 11:39
memberensamblegl6-Aug-12 11:39 
AnswerRe: Lines in 3D space Pin
jrynd7-Aug-12 11:00
memberjrynd7-Aug-12 11:00 
AnswerRe: Lines in 3D space Pin
Florian Rappl30-Jan-13 6:25
mvpFlorian Rappl30-Jan-13 6:25 
AnswerRe: Lines in 3D space Pin
abenedik5-Jun-14 23:27
memberabenedik5-Jun-14 23:27 
Generaljust some info about perfomance Pin
alesterre13-Feb-12 1:24
memberalesterre13-Feb-12 1:24 
QuestionCan i use this project to draw the 3D graph like the link picture Pin
derek091927-Nov-11 5:14
memberderek091927-Nov-11 5:14 
AnswerRe: Can i use this project to draw the 3D graph like the link picture Pin
jrynd7-Aug-12 11:01
memberjrynd7-Aug-12 11:01 
Questioncoloring the mesh Pin
DevoraNur11-Sep-11 23:36
memberDevoraNur11-Sep-11 23:36 
AnswerRe: coloring the mesh Pin
jrynd7-Aug-12 11:37
memberjrynd7-Aug-12 11:37 
QuestionThat is excellent Pin
RugbyLeague22-Jul-11 0:26
memberRugbyLeague22-Jul-11 0:26 
QuestionQuestion Pin
Member 79479618-Jul-11 5:52
memberMember 79479618-Jul-11 5:52 
GeneralThis is unsafe code Pin
jrynd9-Jun-11 4:31
memberjrynd9-Jun-11 4:31 
GeneralRe: This is unsafe code Pin
jrynd14-Jul-11 10:19
memberjrynd14-Jul-11 10:19 
GeneralMy vote of 5 Pin
gaesquivel31-May-11 10:40
membergaesquivel31-May-11 10:40 
Questionhow to get the mesh along the axix Pin
nivaschitturi7-Apr-11 15:47
membernivaschitturi7-Apr-11 15:47 
QuestionHow can I add axis labels? Pin
xfg_xie8-Feb-11 10:44
memberxfg_xie8-Feb-11 10:44 
QuestionHow would I implement a 3d surface. Pin
euandean17-Nov-10 5:46
membereuandean17-Nov-10 5:46 
AnswerRe: How would I implement a 3d surface. Pin
jrynd16-Mar-11 9:31
memberjrynd16-Mar-11 9:31 
GeneralAbsolute 5, but one question need help Pin
ellasun20-Oct-10 17:20
memberellasun20-Oct-10 17:20 
GeneralMy vote of 5 Pin
ZED0229-Apr-10 20:34
memberZED0229-Apr-10 20:34 
Generalthumbs up Pin
naam20021-Mar-10 5:05
membernaam20021-Mar-10 5:05 
GeneralNice work and clear explanation. Pin
jinhu8-Oct-09 21:06
memberjinhu8-Oct-09 21:06 
GeneralMy vote of 2 Pin
anilarawat17-Sep-09 16:46
memberanilarawat17-Sep-09 16:46 
GeneralCompiler Error in TextureMapping.cs Pin
andre1234515-Sep-09 8:35
memberandre1234515-Sep-09 8:35 
GeneralRe: Compiler Error in TextureMapping.cs Pin
Jianzhong Zhang15-Sep-09 11:18
memberJianzhong Zhang15-Sep-09 11:18 
GeneralAwesome Pin
Daniel McGaughran14-Sep-09 19:35
memberDaniel McGaughran14-Sep-09 19:35 
GeneralRe: Awesome Pin
Jianzhong Zhang14-Sep-09 20:24
memberJianzhong Zhang14-Sep-09 20:24 
GeneralRe: Awesome Pin
Jianzhong Zhang14-Sep-09 20:26
memberJianzhong Zhang14-Sep-09 20:26 
GeneralVery, Very Nice Pin
David Roh14-Sep-09 13:23
memberDavid Roh14-Sep-09 13:23 
GeneralRe: Very, Very Nice Pin
Jianzhong Zhang14-Sep-09 20:20
memberJianzhong Zhang14-Sep-09 20:20 
GeneralA few suggestions... Pin
Andrew Rissing11-Sep-09 4:16
memberAndrew Rissing11-Sep-09 4:16 
GeneralRe: A few suggestions... Pin
Jianzhong Zhang11-Sep-09 5:31
memberJianzhong Zhang11-Sep-09 5:31 
GeneralRe: A few suggestions... Pin
Andrew Rissing11-Sep-09 7:50
memberAndrew Rissing11-Sep-09 7:50 
GeneralRe: A few suggestions... Pin
Jianzhong Zhang11-Sep-09 5:44
memberJianzhong Zhang11-Sep-09 5:44 

General General    News News    Suggestion Suggestion    Question Question    Bug Bug    Answer Answer    Joke Joke    Praise Praise    Rant Rant    Admin Admin   

Use Ctrl+Left/Right to switch messages, Ctrl+Up/Down to switch threads, Ctrl+Shift+Left/Right to switch pages.

Permalink | Advertise | Privacy | Terms of Use | Mobile
Web02 | 2.8.170518.1 | Last Updated 7 Sep 2009
Article Copyright 2009 by Jianzhong Zhang
Everything else Copyright © CodeProject, 1999-2017
Layout: fixed | fluid